Backhans, Annette
- Department of Clinical Sciences, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences
Research article2015Peer reviewedOpen access
Alternatives to the use of antimicrobial agents in pig production: A multi-country expert-ranking of perceived effectiveness, feasibility and return on investment : A multi-country expert-ranking of perceived effectiveness, feasibility and return on investment
Postma, Merel; Staerk, Katharina D. C.; Sjoelund, Marie; Backhans, Annette; Beilage, Elisabeth Grosse; Loesken, Svenja; Belloc, Catherine; Collineau, Lucie; Iten, Denise; Visschers, Vivianne; Nielsen, Elisabeth O.; Dewulf, Jeroen
Abstract
Nineteen alternatives to antimicrobial agents were ranked on perceived effectiveness, feasibility and return on investment (ROI) from 0 (not effective, not feasible, no ROI) to 10 (fully effective, completely feasible, maximum ROI) by 111 pig health experts from Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Sweden and Switzerland.The top 5 measures in terms of perceived effectiveness were (1) improved internal biosecurity, (2) improved external biosecurity, (3) improved climate/environmental conditions, (4) high health/Specific Pathogen Free/disease eradication and (5) increased vaccination. The top 5 measures in terms of perceived feasibility were (1) increased vaccination, (2) increased use of anti-inflammatory products, (3) improved water quality, (4) feed quality/optimization and (5) use of zinc/metals. The top 5 measures in terms of perceived ROI were (1) improved internal biosecurity, (2) zinc/metals, (3) diagnostics/action plan, (4) feed quality/optimization and (5) climate/environmental improvements. Univariate linear regression showed that veterinary practitioners rank internal biosecurity, vaccination, use of zinc/metals, feed quality optimization and climate/environmental on average highest, while researchers and professors focused more on increased use of diagnostics and action plans. Financial incentives/penalties ranked low in all countries. Belgian respondents ranked feed quality significantly lower compared to the German respondents while reduction of stocking density was ranked higher in Belgium compared to Denmark. Categorical Principal Component Analysis applied to the average ranking supported the finding that veterinary practitioners had a preference for more practical, common and already known alternatives.The results showed that improvements in biosecurity, increased use of vaccination, use of zinc/metals, feed quality improvement and regular diagnostic testing combined with a clear action plan were perceived to be the most promising alternatives to antimicrobials in industrial pig production based on combined effectiveness, feasibility and ROI. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords
Alternatives to antimicrobial agents; Biosecurity; Management; Vaccination; Zinc oxide; Financial incentives; Diagnostics and action plan; Water and feed quality; Pig production
Published in
Preventive Veterinary Medicine
2015, volume: 118, number: 4, pages: 457-466
Publisher: ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
SLU Authors
Sjölund, Marie
- Department of Clinical Sciences, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences
- National Veterinary Institute (SVA)
- Department of Clinical Sciences, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences
Associated SLU-program
AMR: Bacteria
Global goals (SDG)
SDG2 Zero hunger
SDG3 Good health and well-being
UKÄ Subject classification
Clinical Science
Other Veterinary Science
Publication identifier
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prevetmed.2015.01.010
Permanent link to this page (URI)
https://res.slu.se/id/publ/67036