Skip to main content
Research article - Peer-reviewed, 2022

Uncovering the critical soil moisture thresholds of plant water stress for European ecosystems

Fu, Zheng; Ciais, Philippe; Makowski, David; Bastos, Ana; Stoy, Paul C.; Ibrom, Andreas; Knohl, Alexander; Migliavacca, Mirco; Cuntz, Matthias; Sigut, Ladislav; Peichl, Matthias; Loustau, Denis; El-Madany, Tarek S.; Buchmann, Nina; Gharun, Mana; Janssens, Ivan; Markwitz, Christian; Gruenwald, Thomas; Rebmann, Corinna; Molder, Meelis;
Show more authors


Understanding the critical soil moisture (SM) threshold (theta(crit)) of plant water stress and land surface energy partitioning is a basis to evaluate drought impacts and improve models for predicting future ecosystem condition and climate. Quantifying the theta(crit) across biomes and climates is challenging because observations of surface energy fluxes and SM remain sparse. Here, we used the latest database of eddy covariance measurements to estimate theta(crit) across Europe by evaluating evaporative fraction (EF)-SM relationships and investigating the covariance between vapor pressure deficit (VPD) and gross primary production (GPP) during SM dry-down periods. We found that the theta(crit) and soil matric potential threshold in Europe are 16.5% and -0.7 MPa, respectively. Surface energy partitioning characteristics varied among different vegetation types; EF in savannas had the highest sensitivities to SM in water-limited stage, and the lowest in forests. The sign of the covariance between daily VPD and GPP consistently changed from positive to negative during dry-down across all sites when EF shifted from relatively high to low values. This sign of the covariance changed after longer period of SM decline in forests than in grasslands and savannas. Estimated theta(crit) from the VPD-GPP covariance method match well with the EF-SM method, showing this covariance method can be used to detect the theta(crit). We further found that soil texture dominates the spatial variability of theta(crit) while shortwave radiation and VPD are the major drivers in determining the spatial pattern of EF sensitivities. Our results highlight for the first time that the sign change of the covariance between daily VPD and GPP can be used as an indicator of how ecosystems transition from energy to SM limitation. We also characterized the corresponding theta(crit) and its drivers across diverse ecosystems in Europe, an essential variable to improve the representation of water stress in land surface models.


critical soil moisture threshold; drought; Europe; evaporative fraction; gross primary production; surface energy partitioning; vapor pressure deficit

Published in

Global Change Biology
2022, volume: 28, number: 6, pages: 2111-2123
Publisher: WILEY

Authors' information

Fu, Zheng
Ciais, Philippe
Makowski, David
Universite Paris Saclay
Bastos, Ana
Max Planck Society
Stoy, Paul C.
University of Wisconsin Madison
Ibrom, Andreas
Technical University of Denmark
Knohl, Alexander
University of Gottingen
Migliavacca, Mirco
Max Planck Society
Cuntz, Matthias
Sigut, Ladislav
Global Change Research Centre of the Czech Academy of Sciences
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Department of Forest Ecology and Management
Loustau, Denis
El-Madany, Tarek S.
Max Planck Society
Buchmann, Nina
ETH Zurich
Gharun, Mana
ETH Zurich
Janssens, Ivan
University of Antwerp
Markwitz, Christian
University of Gottingen
Gruenwald, Thomas
Technische Universitat Dresden
Rebmann, Corinna
Helmholtz Association
Molder, Meelis
Lund University
Show more authors

UKÄ Subject classification

Soil Science

Publication Identifiers


URI (permanent link to this page)