Skip to main content
Research article - Peer-reviewed, 2023

Comparative life cycle assessment of conventional and novel microalgae production systems and environmental impact mitigation in urban-industrial symbiosis

Pechsiri, Joseph Santhi; Thomas, Jean-Baptiste E.; El Bahraoui, Naoufel; Acien Fernandez, Francisco Gabriel; Chaouki, Jamal; Chidami, Saad; Tinoco, Rodrigo Rivera; Pena Martin, Jose; Gomez, Cintia; Combe, Michel; Grondahl, Fredrik


The versatility of microalgae biomass as candidates for various products and bioremediation needs motivates interests towards design and implementation of novel microalgae bioreactors. Conventional open-reactors are reliant on large quantities of sunlight and space while yields are constrained by outdoor environment conditions. Conversely, closed-reactor systems like bubble columns reduces these constrains on microalgae growth while occupying far less space at the expense of high energy demands, notably from lighting systems. A novel patented closed reactor design has recently been proposed that improves the bubble column concept with an efficient and effective lighting system. The present study uses Life Cycle Assessment approach to compare the environmental performance of conventional reactors and the proposed internally luminated novel closed reactor design, expressing impacts per kg biostimulant for the Scenedesmus almeriensis harvest from such units. All performance data was collected from a pilot facility in Almeria, Spain. Urban-industrial symbiosis scenarios are also portrayed in the study using wastewater and incinerator flue gas. Results show that under synthetic nutrient and carbon inputs in Spanish pilot operations, the cumulative energy demand for the novel photobioreactors is similar to conventional vertically-stacked horizon bioreactors but are substantially more demanding than conventional open reactors. However, when leveraging renewable energy sources and the photosynthesis process to consume wastestreams in urban-industrial symbiosis scenarios, the novel photobioreactor was able to achieve up to 80 % improvements in several impact categories e.g. eutrophication and climate change. Impact mitigation credits per kg dwt biomass across all energy scenarios in symbiosis amount to asymptotic to 1.8 kg CO(2)eq and asymptotic to 0.09 kg PO4 eq. This highlights that such closed and internally illuminated photobioreactors can be competitive with conventional reactors, and have potential to harness photosynthesis to reduce environmental burdens in an urban-industrial symbiosis setting. Possible economies of scale and the associated potential gains in efficiencies are further discussed.


Biostimulant; Microalgae; Bioreactor; Life cycle assessment; Industrial Symbiosis

Published in

Science of the Total Environment
2023, volume: 854, article number: 158445
Publisher: ELSEVIER

Authors' information

Pechsiri, Joseph Santhi (Pechsiri, Joseph)
Royal Institute of Technology (KTH)
Thomas, Jean-Baptiste E.
Royal Institute of Technology
El Bahraoui, Naoufel
UDICE-French Research Universities
Acien Fernandez, Francisco Gabriel
Universidad de Almeria
Chaouki, Jamal
Polytechnique Montreal
Chidami, Saad
Polytechnique Montreal
Tinoco, Rodrigo Rivera
UDICE-French Research Universities
Pena Martin, Jose
Universidad de Almeria
Gomez, Cintia
Universidad de Almeria
Grondahl, Fredrik
Royal Institute of Technology

UKÄ Subject classification


Publication Identifiers


URI (permanent link to this page)