Skip to main content
SLU publication database (SLUpub)

Research article2024Peer reviewedOpen access

High-solid digestion - A comparison of completely stirred and plug-flow reactor systems

Perman, Ebba; Karlsson, Anna; Westerholm, Maria; Isaksson, Simon; Schnurer, Anna

Abstract

High-solid digestion (HSD) for biogas production is a resource-efficient and sustainable method to treat organic wastes with high total solids content and obtain renewable energy and an organic fertiliser, using a lower dilution rate than in the more common wet digestion process. This study examined the effect of reactor type on the performance of an HSD process, comparing plug-flow (PFR) type reactors developed for continuous HSD processes, and completely stirred-tank reactors (CSTRs) commonly used for wet digestion. The HSD process was operated in thermophilic conditions (52 degrees C), with a mixture of household waste, garden waste and agricultural residues (total solids content 27-28 %). The PFRs showed slightly better performance, with higher specific methane production and nitrogen mineralisation than the CSTRs, while the reduction of volatile solids was the same in both reactor types. Results from 16S rRNA gene sequencing showed a significant difference in the microbial population, potentially related to large differences in stirring speed between the reactor types (1 rpm in PFRs and 70-150 rpm in CSTRs, respectively). The bacterial community was dominated by the genus Defluviitoga in the PFRs and order MBA03 in the CSTRs. For the archaeal community, there was a predominance of the genus Methanoculleus in the PFRs, and of the genera Methanosarcina and Methanothermobacter in the CSTRs. Despite these shifts in microbiology, the results showed that stable digestion of substrates with high total solids content can be achieved in both reactor types, indicating flexibility in the choice of technique for HSD processes.

Keywords

Plug-flow reactors; Completely stirred-tank reactors; High-solid digestion; Process performance; Microbial community structure

Published in

Waste Management
2024, Volume: 189, pages: 265-275 Publisher: PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD