Skip to main content
Research article - Peer-reviewed, 2016

Shared values and deliberative valuation: Future directions

Kenter, Jasper O.; Bryce, Rosalind; Christie, Michael; Cooper, Nigel; Hockley, Neal; Irvine, Katherine N.; Fazey, Ioan; Raymond, Christopher; Reed, Mark; Watson, Verity


Valuation that focuses only on individual values evades the substantial collective and intersubjective meanings, significance and value from ecosystems. Shared, plural and cultural values of ecosystems constitute a diffuse and interdisciplinary field of research, covering an area that links questions around value ontology, elicitation and aggregation with questions of participation, ethics, and social justice. Synthesising understanding from various contributions to this Special Issue of Ecosystem Services, and with a particular focus on deliberation and deliberative valuation, we discuss key findings and present 35 future research questions in eight topic areas: 1) the ontology of shared values; 2) the role of catalyst and conflict points; 3) shared values and cultural ecosystem services; 4) transcendental values; 5) the process and outcomes of deliberation; 6) deliberative monetary valuation; 7) value aggregation, meta-values and 'rules of the game'; and 8) integrating valuation methods. The results of this Special Issue and these key questions can help develop a more extensive evidence base to mature the area and develop environmental valuation into a more pluralistic, comprehensive, robust, legitimate and effective way of safeguarding ecosystems and their services for the future.


Shared values; Transcendental values; Integrated valuation; Deliberative monetary valuation; Ethics; Cultural ecosystem services

Published in

Ecosystem Services
2016, volume: 21, pages: 358-371

Authors' information

Kenter, Jasper O.
Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)
Bryce, Rosalind
University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)
Christie, Michael
Aberystwyth University
Cooper, Nigel
Anglia Ruskin University
Hockley, Neal
Bangor University
Irvine, Katherine N.
The James Hutton Institute
Fazey, Ioan
University of Dundee
Raymond, Christopher
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Department of Landscape Architecture, Planning and Management
Reed, Mark
University of Newcastle upon Tyne
Watson, Verity
University of Aberdeen

UKÄ Subject classification

Environmental Sciences
Applied Psychology

Publication Identifiers


URI (permanent link to this page)